30-Year All-Star Baseball Teams

(Selected by Ted Silary; Appeared in Phila. Daily News July '07)

Return to TedSilary.com Home Page


Gubicza, Davis head star-studded cast

ANYONE SEEN the last 30 years? Where'd they go?

They say time flies when you're having fun. When you're having this much fun, they zoom past at a speed that could break the sound barrier.

This past spring marked the end of my third full decade covering city leagues high school baseball for the good, ol' Daily News and you know what that means ... yet another 30-year all-star team!

Don't all groan at once.

Thirty-year basketball and football teams were published after the 2004-05 hoops and '05 grid seasons, respectively, because for those sports my 30-year period included time spent covering scholastic sports at the original Philadelphia Bulletin.

Baseball was not covered extensively there, so All-City baseball squads did not debut until '78 in the People Paper.

Anyway . . . On these pages you'll find separate teams for the Public, Catholic and Inter-Ac and, of course, overall All-City squads.

Though it's difficult not to be influenced by what happens to players during college and beyond, a strong attempt has been made to make rankings based only on high school performance.

So, if a guy was "only'' second- team All-City in high school, he now won't find himself listed as an upper-echelon honoree. In fact, most of the guys on the three All-City teams twice earned first-team laurels.

The positions are self-explanatory except for DP. That stands for "dual purpose'' and allows us to honor guys who were outstanding as pitchers and position players.

That came in handy with regard to 1991 graduates Keith Conway (Archbishop Carroll) and Dan Kusters (Archbishop Wood). They were outstanding as seniors and juniors, witness the fact they swapped Player and Pitcher of the Year awards from one season to the next.

Now, for our big awards:

The Top Pitcher award for the 30-year period goes to Mark Gubicza, a 1981 Penn Charter graduate. In his senior season, Gubicza posted an 8-1 record with an 0.48 ERA. In 58 2/3 innings, thanks largely to a 92-mph fastball, he allowed only 27 hits and 25 walks, while striking out 83.

Early that spring, the Quakers spent some time in Florida and Gubicza recorded five whiffs in a three-inning appearance against a squad of first-year Phillies farmhands. Later, in the weeks immediately preceding the draft, close to 30 scouts showed up for Gubicza's appearances and he was a second-round selection (No. 34) of the Kansas City Royals. He signed within a week and later enjoyed a 14-year major league career, highlighted by a 20-win season in 1988.

We remain in the Inter-Ac League for our Top Player, and that award goes to 1995 Malvern Prep grad Ben Davis.

Davis, a switch-hitting catcher, created an incredible buzz among scouts and was the No. 2 overall pick, by the San Diego Padres, in that spring's draft.

Davis hit .507 with four doubles, seven triples and six homers, and drove in 37 runs. Just as impressive was his defensive wizardry. Only 12 guys tried to steal against him. Eight were rung up, and Padres scout Rene Mons called Davis' arm "the best I've ever seen.''

Baseball America, using scouts' judgments, called Davis the best high school catcher they'd seen since 1974 (Dale Murphy, who later became a high-quality big-league outfielder).

Davis played in the majors from 1998 to 2004. His best year was in '01, when he posted 11 homers and 57 RBI. After beginning this season with the independent Camden Riversharks, he is now playing for the Las Vegas 51s, the Dodgers' farm club in the Triple A Pacific Coast League.

ALL-CITY

FIRST TEAM
1B Howie Freiling Northeast '84
1B Tito Nanni Chestnut Hill ‘78
INF Mike Costanzo Carroll '02
INF Josh McKinley Malvern '98
INF Jay Aquilante Carroll ‘97

OF Dan Cataline Ryan '80

OF Chris Lubanski Kennedy-Kenrick '03
OF Rick Burns Egan '83
C Ben Davis Malvern ‘95
DH John Marzano Central ‘81
DP Keith Conway Carroll ‘91
DP Dan Kusters Wood ‘91
P Mark Gubicza Penn Charter ‘81
P John Price Ryan ‘00
P Mark Adzick Penn Charter ‘07
SECOND TEAM
1B Jack Stanczak La Salle ‘89
INF Kengo Honda Washington '87

INF Mark Iacovelli Judge ‘85
INF Rob Patete Roxborough '84
OF Bob Loscalzo Dougherty '78
OF Mark Steffens Gtn. Academy '88
OF Sean Grieve Gtn. Academy ‘04
C Mike Fuchs Carroll ‘97
DH Bob Zupcic Egan ‘84

DP Rich Fernandez Central ‘87
DP Harry Carr Roman ‘92
DP Dan Waters La Salle ‘03
P Tom Stauffer Bonner ‘78
P Kevin McGerry Judge ‘97
P Matt Zielinski La Salle ‘05
THIRD TEAM
1B Glenn Davis Malvern ‘94
INF Ruben Amaro Penn Charter ‘83

INF Mike Galetta Haver. School ‘07
INF Courtney Batts Penn Charter ‘93
OF Lou Spadaccini Neumann ‘92
OF Pat Kane W. Catholic ‘79
OF David Amaro Penn Charter ‘80
C Jesse Levis Northeast ‘86
DH Scott Hunter Northeast ‘93
DP Dave Miller Chestnut Hill ‘92
DP Deron Miller Franklin ‘84
P Gene Schall La Salle ‘88
P Andy Meltzer Northeast ‘84
P Bill Mendek W. Catholic ‘80

--

ALL-CATHOLIC
FIRST TEAM
1B Jack Stanczak La Salle '89

INF Mike Costanzo Carroll '02
INF Jay Aquilante Carroll '97
INF Mark Iacovelli Judge '85
OF Dan Cataline Ryan '80

OF Chris Lubanski Kennedy-Kenrick '03
OF Rick Burns Egan '83
C Mike Fuchs Carroll '97
DH Bob Zupcic Egan ‘84

DP Keith Conway Carroll ‘91
DP Dan Kusters Wood ‘91
P John Price Ryan ‘00
P Tom Stauffer Bonner ‘78
P Kevin McGerry Judge ‘97
SECOND TEAM
1B Kevin Ward Bonner ‘05
INF Ted Dezzi O’Hara ‘84
INF Bob File Judge ‘94

INF Kerry Cahill Judge ‘86
OF Bob Loscalzo Dougherty ‘78
OF Lou Spadaccini Neumann ‘92
OF Pat Kane W. Catholic ‘79
C Scott Lawler Kenrick ‘92
DH Jim Fuchs Carroll ‘99
DP Harry Carr Roman ‘92
DP Dan Waters La Salle ‘03
P Matt Zielinski La Salle ‘06
P Gene Schall La Salle ‘88
P Bill Mendek W. Catholic ‘80
THIRD TEAM
1B Lou DeTitto Ryan ‘01
INF Marty Carey O’Hara ‘89
INF Sean Hollenbach Wood ‘90
INF Mike Essery O’Hara ‘02
OF John O’Brien Dougherty ‘83
OF Joe McEwing Egan ‘90
OF Dave Mastropietro N. Catholic ‘87
C Tom Bonk N. Catholic ‘79
DH Dale Curry Judge ‘04
DP Mike Kerrigan Wood ‘87
DP Matt Compton Judge ‘06
P Jeff Randazzo O’Hara ‘99
P Chris Gies Judge ‘87
P Chris Heck N. Catholic ‘95

HONORABLE MENTION
(Two Per School)
Bonner: Dan Mulholland, p, ’98; Jack McCoy, of, ’89.
Carroll: Frank Gailey, p, ’04; Gerard Oakes, p, ’00.
C-E (Egan): Brian Herman, p, ’06; John Malloy, of, ’06.

Dougherty: Ed Law, inf,’81; Jason Streeper, of, ’97.
Judge: Pat Waninger, p, ’81; Harry Murray, of, ’82.
K-K (Kenrick): Tom Sergio, inf, ’93; Mike Migliarese, of, ’85.
La Salle: Roger Harrington, of, ’92; Ryan Parfitt, of, ’01.
N-G (Neumann): Ray Russo, of, ’93; Rob Carfagno, p, ’88.
North: Jim Hooven, p, ’80; Stan Orzechowski, of, ’04.
O’Hara: Kenny Grant, p, ’01; Eric Parker, p, ’90.
Roman: Bill Black, inf, ’93; Pat DiCicco, c, ’83;
Ryan: Don Bradley, inf, ’80; Jim McNesby, inf, ’83.
St. James: Bob Christy, 1b, ‘85; Tom McNeely, inf, ’85.
SJ Prep: Ed Turner, inf, ’00; Steve Harris, of, ’99.
West: Tom McDevitt, p, ’85; Steve Sala, p, ’93.
Wood: Brian Schaller, dh, ’93; Chris Crawford, inf, ’06.

---

ALL-PUBLIC
FIRST TEAM
1B Howie Freiling Northeast ‘84
INF Kengo Honda Washington ‘87
INF Rob Patete Roxborough ‘84
INF Bobby Higginson Frankford ‘88
OF Steve Harvey Franklin ‘78
OF Ernell Harley Mastbaum ‘81
OF Dave Coyne Roxborough ‘83
C Jesse Levis Northeast ‘86
DH John Marzano Central ‘81
DP Rich Fernandez Central ‘87

DP Deron Miller Franklin ‘84

P Andy Meltzer Northeast ‘84
P Joe Farina Frankford ‘04
P Scott Vogel Northeast ‘80

SECOND TEAM
1B Ed Durfor Frankford ’00
INF Ed Lowery Roxborough ‘78
INF Wilson Duran Olney ‘95
INF Stu Drossner Washington ’81
OF Mike McDonald Lincoln ‘95
OF Lamont McGill Franklin ’80
OF Frank Rubin Washington ‘87
C Joe Turvey Roxborough ‘89
DH Scott Hunter Northeast ‘93
DP Dave Firth Frankford ‘02
DP Terrell Berthau Franklin ‘89
P Al Baur Southern ‘86
P Bruce Konick Frankford ‘81

P Eric Kay Roxborough ‘89

THIRD TEAM
1B John DeLeon Univ. City ‘79
INF Ed Bowman Mastbaum ’97
INF George Bobe Edison ’80
INF Bob Sim Northeast ’85
OF Anthony Franklin Franklin ’84
OF Jim Krzywicki Central ’89
OF Larry Abney Olney ’93
C Billy Dunfee Bartram ‘87

DH Tom Dunfee Bartram ‘78
DP Mike Gibbs Roxborough ’02
DP Jared Farbman Central ‘07
P Ron Clarkson Lincoln ‘01
P Bill Gobeler Washington ’79
P Rich Danson Central ‘83
HONORABLE MENTION

(*Up to Two per School)
Central: Pete Whittle, p, ’99; Joe Dugan, of, ’94.
Edison: Abel Rios, 1b, ’79; Omar Monserrate, dh, ‘98.
Frankford: Ramon Reyes, c, ’06; Luis Alicea, inf, ’05.
Germantown: Ricky Ford, inf, ’79; Chris Wyche, of, ‘85.
Mastbaum: Mike Valentino, 1b,’81; Jim McKinstry, p, ’85.
Northeast: Terry Rooney, c, ’96; Jeff Weiss, inf, ’91.
Olney: Jose Caraballo, of, ’95.
Overbrook: Eric Pugh, inf, ’99.
Roxborough: Mike Miller, p, ’90; Vinnie Passalacqua, p, ’96.
Southern: Dominic Raia, inf, ’87; Rob Hale, p, ’89.
Washington: Jeff Capriotti, dh, ’82; Kevin Higgins, p, ’87.
*-limited to schools with first team All-City honorees.

 

---

 

ALL-INTER-AC
FIRST TEAM

1B Tito Nanni Chestnut Hill ‘78 
INF Josh McKinley Malvern ‘98
INF Ruben Amaro Penn Charter ‘83
INF Mike Galetta Haver. School ‘07
OF Mark Steffens Gtn. Academy ‘88
OF Sean Grieve Gtn. Academy ‘04
OF David Amaro Penn Charter ‘80

C Ben Davis Malvern ‘95
DH Dan Dougherty Episcopal ‘80
DP Dave Miller Chestnut Hill ‘92
DP Joe Larkin Penn Charter ‘99
P Mark Gubicza Penn Charter ‘81
P Mark Adzick Penn Charter ‘07
P Mike DeNoia Malvern ‘83
P Mike Samuel Penn Charter ‘94

SECOND TEAM
1B Glenn Davis Malvern ‘94

INF Courtney Batts Penn Charter ‘93
INF Rick Welsh Gtn. Academy ‘94
INF Craig Shumock Gtn. Academy’78
OF Tom Grandieri Malvern ‘07
OF Ryan Nanni Penn Charter ‘05

OF John Barr Gtn. Academy ‘07
C Frank DeSantis Penn Charter ‘78
DH Steve Floirendo Penn Charter ‘86
DP Matt Bruderek Gtn. Academy ‘04
DP Frank Maletta Penn Charter ‘95
P Joe Bruderek Gtn. Academy ‘96
P Mike Koplove Chestnut Hill ‘95
P Dave Healy Penn Charter ‘86
HONORABLE MENTION
(Two per School)
Chestnut Hill: Anthony Cafagna, p, ’07; Mike Brown, c, ‘00.

Episcopal: Adam Murray, inf, ’02; Mike Abate, inf, ‘93.
Gtn. Academy: Joe Matteo, p, ’04; Tyler Stampone, inf, ’05.
Haver. School: E.J. Moyer, p, ’91; Steve Compton, inf, ’00.
Malvern: Matt O’Brien, of, ’93; Phil Gosselin, inf, ’07.

Penn Charter: Kenny Devenney, of, ’01; John Loughery, inf, ’78.