Philadelphia High School Sports
All-City
Honorees, by School, M to Z
(Sorted by First Name)
(First, Second or
Third Team in Football/Basketball/Baseball)
(Guys with nicknames appear at beginning of entries for their real name)
**All-City baseball/football teams not selected, 2019-forward.**
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
| SCHOOL | SPORT | TEAM | YEAR |
| Malvern | |||
| Alex Forte | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Alex Hornibrook | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Andrew Mackrides | FB | First | 2003 |
| Anthony Fenza | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Ben Davis | Bask | Third | 1995 |
| Ben Davis | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Ben Davis | Base | First | 1994 |
| Ben Davis | Base | First | 1995 |
| Bill Corbett | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Bill Lockhart | FB | First | 1984 |
| Bill Lockhart | Base | First | 1985 |
| Billy Conners | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Billy Conners | FB | First | 2008 |
| Billy Corcoran | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Billy Corcoran | Base | First | 2017 |
| Billy Corcoran | Base | First | 2018 |
| Bob Carey | FB | First | 1972 |
| Bob Eyler | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Bobby Hill | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Bobby Panchisin | FB | First | 2008 |
| Brady Devereux | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Brendan Carney | FB | First | 2000 |
| Brendan Carney | FB | First | 2001 |
| Brendan Carney | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Brendan Kilpatrick | Bask | Third | 2011 |
| Brendan Kilpatrick | Bask | First | 2012 |
| Brian Buckley | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Brian Gallagher | FB | First | 1991 |
| Brian Giacchino | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Brian Grandieri | Bask | Second | 2003 |
| Brian Grandieri | Bask | First | 2004 |
| Brian Heavens | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Brian Kolmer | FB | First | 1971 |
| Brian Wall | FB | Third | 1980 |
| Bryan McKernan | Base | Third | 1992 |
| Bryan McKernan | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Cam Williams | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Chance DiFebbo | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Chance DiFebbo | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Charlie Floyd | Bask | Third | 1972 |
| Charlie Floyd | Bask | First | 1973 |
| Charlie Floyd | Bask | First | 1974 |
| Chris "Goose" Gosik | Base | First | 2008 |
| Chris "Goose" Gosik | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Chris Butera | Base | First | 2015 |
| Chris Cowell | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Chris Downs | FB | First | 1996 |
| Chris Downs | FB | First | 1997 |
| Chris Elmes | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Chris Emper | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Chris Layne | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Chris Muntz | FB | First | 1999 |
| Chris Newell | Base | First | 2017 |
| Chris Newell | Base | First | 2018 |
| Chris O'Brien | FB | Third | 2009 |
| Chris O'Brien | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Chris O'Brien | Base | First | 2011 |
| Chris Tillman | FB | Third | 1990 |
| Chris Treston | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Chris Treston | FB | First | 1986 |
| Chris Wayock | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Chuck McAnally | Base | Third | 1983 |
| CJ Mooney | FB | First | 2008 |
| Connor Dillon | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Connor Mahoney | FB | First | 2010 |
| Connor Mahoney | FB | First | 2011 |
| Craig O'Brien | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Craig O'Brien | FB | First | 1978 |
| D.J. Driscoll | FB | First | 2001 |
| Dan Bonner | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Dan Grandieri | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Dan Grandieri | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Dan Onorato | FB | First | 2003 |
| Dan Riordan | FB | First | 1974 |
| Dave Lynch | FB | First | 2015 |
| Dave O'Brien | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Dave O'Brien | Base | First | 1996 |
| Dave Rogers | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Dave Rogers | FB | First | 1986 |
| David Orr | FB | First | 1980 |
| David Orr | Base | Second | 1980 |
| David Orr | Base | First | 1981 |
| Dennis Morgan | FB | Second | 1984 |
| DeQuann "Bootsie" Walker | Bask | Third | 2010 |
| Derek Duclos | Base | First | 2001 |
| Derrick Downs | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Derrick Downs | FB | First | 1995 |
| Deuce Turner | Bask | First | 2019 |
| Deuce Turner | Bask | First | 2020 |
| Doug Borgerson | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Drew Gunther | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Drew Gunther | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Drew Hayes | Base | Third | 2011 |
| Drew Hayes | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Drew Parvin | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Drew Parvin | Base | Third | 1980 |
| Ed Deal | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Ed Devine | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Eric Carroll | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Frank Carr | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Frank Heller | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Frank Oschell | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Gardner Nutter | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Gardner Nutter | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Garrett Reilly | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Gary Duda | Bask | Second | 1988 |
| Gary Duda | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Gary Duda | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Gene Chakejian | FB | Second | 1987 |
| George Twardy | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Glenn Davis | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Glenn Davis | Base | First | 1994 |
| Gordy Bryan | Bask | Third | 1976 |
| Gordy Bryan | Bask | Second | 1977 |
| Gordy Bryan | Bask | Third | 1978 |
| Greg Oschell | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Hayden Mahoney | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Herb Beck | FB | First | 1973 |
| Herb Beck | FB | First | 1974 |
| Hugh McGettigan | FB | First | 1977 |
| Hunter Jones | FB | First | 1991 |
| Hunter Paulus | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Ian Mitchell | FB | First | 2005 |
| Jack Moran | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Jacob Rebisz | FB | First | 2013 |
| Jacob Rebisz | FB | First | 2014 |
| Jake Glavin | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Jake Glavin | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Jake Hornibrook | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Jake Hornibrook | FB | First | 2018 |
| James Connelly | FB | Third | 2008 |
| James Spinelli | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Jeff Caldwell | FB | First | 1987 |
| Jeff Glackin | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Jeff Kiessel | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Jim Bruder | FB | Third | 1993 |
| Jim Judge | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Jim Lynch | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Jim Martini | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Jim Rullo | Bask | Third | 1989 |
| Jim Woodward | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Jimmie Cotton | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Jimmy Kingsbury | Base | Second | 2016 |
| Jimmy Kingsbury | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Joe Basiura | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Joe Basiura | FB | First | 2017 |
| Joe Buckley | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Joe Buckley | FB | First | 2006 |
| Joe Carlini | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Joe Carter | Base | Second | 1991 |
| Joe Coffey | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Joe DiTrolio | FB | First | 2009 |
| Joe Hoban | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Joe Nilan | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Joe Nilan | FB | First | 2011 |
| Joe Poduslenko | Base | First | 2012 |
| Joe Poduslenko | Base | First | 2013 |
| Joe Price | FB | First | 2008 |
| Joe Ravert | Base | First | 2012 |
| Joe Rosati | FB | First | 1974 |
| Joe Sheridan | FB | First | 1973 |
| Joe Sullivan | FB | Second | 1979 |
| John Betz | FB | Second | 1979 |
| John Bradford | FB | Second | 1978 |
| John Bradford | FB | Second | 2011 |
| John Dwyer | FB | Third | 1992 |
| John Gentile | Base | First | 2008 |
| John Heavens | FB | Third | 1995 |
| John McBratnie | FB | Second | 1988 |
| John Nassib | FB | First | 2013 |
| John O'Sullivan | FB | First | 1976 |
| John Willcox | Bask | Third | 1974 |
| Jon Dollfus | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Jordan Majors | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Josh McKinley | Base | Third | 1996 |
| Josh McKinley | Base | First | 1997 |
| Josh McKinley | Base | First | 1998 |
| Justin Halladay | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Keith Maguire | FB | First | 2017 |
| Keith Maguire | FB | First | 2018 |
| Kevin Barr | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Kevin Barr | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Kevin Bradley | FB | First | 1980 |
| Kevin Kerns | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Kevin Kiessel | FB | First | 1976 |
| Kevin McKernan | Base | Second | 1994 |
| Kevin Pellegrini | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Liam Dabagian | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Luke Leslie | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Mark Camut | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Mark Tiberi | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Marlon Miller | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Matt Brady | Base | Third | 1998 |
| Matt Maul | Base | First | 2014 |
| Matt O'Brien | Base | First | 1993 |
| Matt Skellan | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Matt Skellan | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Michael Meehan | FB | First | 2002 |
| Michael Mooney | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Michael Mooney | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Mike Ambrose | FB | First | 1999 |
| Mike Augsberger | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Mike Augsberger | FB | First | 1986 |
| Mike Cappelletti | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Mike Ceribelli | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Mike Civitella | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Mike DeNoia | Base | First | 1983 |
| Mike Laino | Base | First | 1982 |
| Mike Lorentson | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Mike Lorentson | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Mike Lubanski | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Mike Lubanski | Base | First | 2009 |
| Mike Meehan | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Mike Melvin | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Mike Pinto | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Mike Ryan | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Mike Schlichtig | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Mike Styer | Base | Second | 2014 |
| Mike Treston | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Neil Willis | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Neil Willis | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Nick Bateman | Base | First | 2011 |
| Nick Bateman | Base | First | 2012 |
| Nick Busillo | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Nick Busillo | Base | Third | 2008 |
| Nick Gueriera | FB | Third | 2018 |
| O'Shaan Allison | FB | First | 2015 |
| O'Shaan Allison | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Pat Clary | FB | Second | 2000 |
| Pat Clary | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Pat Purcell | Bask | Third | 1977 |
| Pat Purcell | Bask | Third | 1978 |
| Pat Sheridan | FB | First | 1974 |
| Pat Van Horn | FB | First | 1977 |
| Pat Van Horn | FB | First | 1978 |
| Paul Keldsen | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Paul Ostick | FB | First | 2005 |
| Paul Ostick | FB | First | 2006 |
| Paul Phelan | FB | Second | 1978 |
| Paul Phelan | FB | First | 1979 |
| Phil DeAngelis | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Phil Gosselin | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Phil Gosselin | Base | First | 2007 |
| Quincy Watson | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Quincy Watson | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Rich Devine | FB | First | 1975 |
| Rich Jones | FB | First | 1978 |
| Rob Bates | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Rob Levan | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Rob McCabe | FB | Third | 2008 |
| Rob McCarry | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Rod Krasley | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Ross Barna | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Ryan Betz | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Ryan Betz | FB | First | 2017 |
| Ryan Edginton | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Ryan Edginton | Base | First | 1999 |
| Ryan Murray | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Ryan Nassib | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Ryan Nassib | FB | First | 2007 |
| Ryan Polley | FB | First | 1994 |
| Ryan Polley | Bask | Second | 1995 |
| Ryan Williams | Bask | Third | 2022 |
| Sean Dougherty | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Sean Mooney | FB | First | 2010 |
| Sebastian Costantini | FB | First | 2018 |
| Shane Muntz | Base | First | 2016 |
| Shane Muntz | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Shannan Green | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Shaun Gallagher | Base | Second | 1998 |
| Shawn Quinn | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Shawn Wilson | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Stan Brown | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Stephen Burns | Base | Second | 2002 |
| Steve Donnelly | FB | First | 1975 |
| Steve Galczenski | FB | First | 1995 |
| Steve Layne | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Steve Nesmith | Bask | Second | 1981 |
| Steve O'Brien | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Steve Perpiglia | Bask | Third | 2012 |
| Steve Robinson | Base | First | 2013 |
| Steve Ryan | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Steve Ryan | FB | First | 1983 |
| Steve Sullivan | FB | Third | 1980 |
| T.J. Cascio | FB | Second | 2001 |
| T.J. Cascio | FB | First | 2002 |
| Terry Pitt | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Terry Pitt | FB | Third | 1982 |
| Tim Cooney | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Tim Cooney | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Tim Cooney | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Tim Kerns | Base | First | 1988 |
| Tim McEndy | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Tim Quinn | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Tim Quinn | Base | First | 2015 |
| Toby Booker | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Tom Coyne | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Tom Grandieri | Base | Second | 2005 |
| Tom Grandieri | Base | First | 2006 |
| Tom Nagy | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Tony Lee | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Tony Liberatore | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Trevor Morris | FB | Second | 2014 |
| Trey Womack | FB | First | 2005 |
| Troy Gallen | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Troy Gallen | FB | First | 2013 |
| Ty Young | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Ty Young | Base | First | 2010 |
| TyGee Leach | FB | Third | 2017 |
| TyGee Leach | FB | First | 2018 |
| Wally Shields | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Wally Shields | FB | First | 1973 |
| Will Romanowicz | Base | First | 2004 |
| Zac Fernandez | FB | First | 2016 |
| Mastbaum | |||
| Abdullah Sams | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Akeem Thompson | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Antoine Brown | FB | First | 1994 |
| Antonio Sowell | FB | Second | 1998 |
| Arlan Johnson | FB | First | 1999 |
| Barry Williams | FB | First | 1990 |
| Bill Freitag | Base | Second | 1987 |
| Bill Onslager | Base | Third | 1978 |
| Bill Onslager | Base | First | 1979 |
| Billl McGrath | FB | First | 1972 |
| Bob Browne | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Bob Browne | Base | First | 1984 |
| Bob Freitag | Base | Third | 1987 |
| Bob Freitag | Base | First | 1988 |
| Bobby Deal | FB | First | 1971 |
| Brian Pichalsky | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Chafie Fields | FB | First | 1993 |
| Chafie Fields | FB | First | 1994 |
| Chris DeShields | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Chris DeShields | FB | First | 2001 |
| Chuck Westergon | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Danny Hughes | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Darin "Munchy" Mason | Bask | Third | 1984 |
| Darren Keith | Bask | Second | 1982 |
| Derreck Orr | Bask | Third | 1986 |
| Ed Bowman | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Ed Bowman | FB | First | 1996 |
| Ed Bowman | Base | Second | 1996 |
| Ed Bowman | Base | First | 1997 |
| Ed Coffin | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Erik Wright | FB | Third | 1989 |
| Ernell Harley | Base | Second | 1980 |
| Ernell Harley | Base | First | 1981 |
| Fred Maier | FB | First | 1975 |
| Galen Baker | Bask | Third | 1973 |
| Harold Akers | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Harry Fernandez | Base | Third | 1984 |
| Harry Fernandez | Base | Second | 1985 |
| Hasan Jones | FB | Second | 1998 |
| James Jackson | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Jeff Arrington | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Jerald Lyons | FB | Second | 1993 |
| Jim Conn | FB | First | 1993 |
| Jim Hughes | FB | Third | 1995 |
| Jim McKinstry | Base | First | 1985 |
| John Grone | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Jose Dones | Base | First | 1986 |
| Joseph Carmichael | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Jovan Pratt | FB | Second | 2003 |
| Keith Sadowski | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Kevin Benton | Bask | Third | 1989 |
| Kevin Benton | Bask | First | 1990 |
| Kevin Harris | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Kyle Shedrick | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Lamont Waters | FB | Second | 1992 |
| Leo McClelland | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Marc Baxter | FB | First | 1990 |
| Marcus Godfrey | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Marcus Godfrey | FB | First | 1995 |
| Mark Brighter | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Markies Tavares | FB | Second | 2004 |
| Maurice Tucker | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Michael Malave | FB | First | 1974 |
| Mike Kessler | FB | First | 1975 |
| Mike Przybyszewski | FB | First | 1973 |
| Mike Valentino | Base | First | 1981 |
| Neal Robinson | Bask | Third | 1977 |
| Paul Stokley | FB | First | 1976 |
| Rasheen Tookes | FB | First | 2008 |
| Ray Thompson | Bask | First | 1978 |
| Reuben McCoy | Bask | Second | 1978 |
| Rich Hallacker | FB | First | 1973 |
| Shaihie Wynder | FB | First | 1988 |
| Sherrod Evers | FB | First | 2004 |
| Steve Head | FB | Second | 1973 |
| Sydney Sheppard | FB | First | 1971 |
| Sydney Sheppard | Bask | Second | 1972 |
| Timmy Brown | Bask | First | 1982 |
| Tom Brown | Base | Third | 1986 |
| Tomar Taylor | FB | First | 1989 |
| Ty "Magic" Cromwell | Bask | Third | 1986 |
| Tyree Stone-Davis | FB | Third | 2010 |
| Tyrin Stone-Davis | FB | Second | 2010 |
| Uhuru "Joby" Hamiter | FB | First | 1990 |
| Warren Hawthorne | Bask | Second | 1985 |
| Wayne Wilson | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Will Richards | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Wilson Palm | FB | First | 1972 |
| Masterman | |||
| David Ashbridge | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Harry Taggart | Base | Second | 2013 |
| Nate Vahedi | Base | Second | 2012 |
| Zahir Carrington | Bask | Third | 2006 |
| Mastery North | |||
| Armani Fuller-Williams | FB | Third | 2013 |
| Daeqwon Plowden | Bask | Third | 2017 |
| DeJason Ellis | FB | Third | 2014 |
| DeJason Ellis | FB | First | 2015 |
| Jalil Nichols | FB | Third | 2013 |
| James Johnson | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Jamir Reed | Bask | Third | 2019 |
| Jermaine Norris | FB | First | 2013 |
| Math, Civics & Science | |||
| Jeremiah "Lump" Worthem | Bask | Second | 2013 |
| Malik Archer | Bask | Third | 2017 |
| Mike Watkins | Bask | Third | 2014 |
| Samir Doughty | Bask | First | 2014 |
| Samir Doughty | Bask | First | 2015 |
| Nisine "Wooga" Poplar | Bask | First | 2020 |
| McDevitt | |||
| Andrew Brown | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Andrew Metro | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Antonio Cupit | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Antonio Cupit | FB | First | 1985 |
| Austin Alcorn | FB | Secon | 2018 |
| Ben Payne | FB | First | 1994 |
| Bill Doyle | FB | Third | 1988 |
| Bill Ring | FB | Third | 1991 |
| Bob Arnold | FB | First | 1982 |
| Brandon Edwards | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Brendan Hanagan | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Brian Mitros | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Brian O'Meara | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Brian Quigg | FB | Second | 1986 |
| Brian Quigg | FB | First | 1987 |
| Brian Rodgers | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Carl Norris | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Chris Conlin | FB | First | 1982 |
| Chris Kittredge | FB | Second | 1996 |
| Chris Owens | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Damian Jordan | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Dan Fiorella | FB | Third | 2016 |
| Dan Taylor | FB | First | 1987 |
| Darren Wright | FB | First | 2011 |
| Dave Melcher | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Dave Melcher | Base | Third | 2001 |
| Delano Turnipseed | FB | Second | 1984 |
| Derick Pickett | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Derick Pickett | FB | First | 1988 |
| Donny Watkins | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Dontae Mason | FB | Second | 2015 |
| Drew Siegfried | FB | First | 2009 |
| Eric Elmer | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Fred Hanes | FB | First | 1996 |
| Fred Mancini | Base | Third | 1994 |
| Gary Burns | FB | Second | 1980 |
| Gary Postell | FB | First | 2010 |
| Gavin Lawrence | FB | First | 1990 |
| Greg Jandrisitz | FB | First | 1996 |
| Jake Kolen | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Jamil Manigo | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Jaron Macon | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Jason Golderer | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Jim Gordon | FB | Second | 1976 |
| Jim Mahoney | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Jim Surdykowski | FB | Second | 2006 |
| Joe Mitros | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Joe Quigg | FB | First | 1979 |
| Joe Vitelli | FB | First | 1983 |
| John Gorman | FB | Third | 2004 |
| John O'Connell | Bask | Second | 1988 |
| John Stuart | FB | First | 1990 |
| Jon-Luke Peaker | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Justin Fisher | FB | First | 1995 |
| Keith Householder | FB | First | 1989 |
| Keith Young | FB | Third | 2011 |
| Ken Arrington | FB | First | 1993 |
| Ken Conlin | FB | Third | 1979 |
| Kevin Greene | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Kevin Greene | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Kevin Pinkos | Base | Third | 1995 |
| Lamar McPherson | FB | First | 2004 |
| LeVar Talley | FB | Second | 1994 |
| LeVar Talley | FB | First | 1995 |
| Lonnie Rice | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Lonnie Rice | FB | First | 2018 |
| Manny Harrison | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Mark "Shark" Finley | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Mark Dianno | FB | First | 1985 |
| Mark Zataveski | FB | Second | 1989 |
| Mark Zataveski | FB | First | 1990 |
| Matt Bucksar | FB | First | 1989 |
| Matt Conroy | Base | Third | 2010 |
| Matt Conroy | FB | First | 2010 |
| Matt Kolen | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Matt Moyer | FB | Third | 1999 |
| Matt Welsh | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Matt Wixted | FB | Second | 1983 |
| Max Bryson | FB | Second | 2016 |
| Michael Stephen Anderson | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Mike DeCristafano | Base | Third | 2007 |
| Mike Dougherty | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Mike Hagarty | FB | Second | 1999 |
| Mike Hagarty | Base | Third | 1999 |
| Mike Hagarty | Base | Second | 2000 |
| Mike Montague | FB | First | 1983 |
| Mike Watkins | FB | Third | 1998 |
| Mike Wojcik | FB | First | 2005 |
| Pat Lawn | FB | Second | 1982 |
| Pat Watkins | FB | First | 1995 |
| Paul DiCicco | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Phil DiMaria | FB | First | 1987 |
| Richard Cotton | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Rick Williams | FB | Second | 1994 |
| Robert McHugh | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Robert McHugh | FB | First | 2002 |
| Robert Smith | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Scott Young | FB | First | 1987 |
| Sean Hughes | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Sean Tuffy | FB | Third | 1997 |
| Stephen "Chief" Yuan | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Stephen "Chief" Yuan | FB | First | 2007 |
| Steve Malin | FB | First | 1999 |
| Terence Wiggins | FB | First | 1991 |
| Tom Taylor | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Tymere Wilder | FB | Third | 2012 |
| Tyrell Long | Bask | First | 2014 |
| Tyrone Fowler | FB | Second | 2018 |
| Wayne Hunter | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Zay Scott | FB | Third | 2018 |
| Neumann / Neumann-Goretti | |||
| To Base '04 / FB '04 Forward | |||
| Anthony Grosso | Base | First | 1986 |
| Anthony Marinucci | Base | Second | 1986 |
| Anthony Sheridan | FB | Third | 1992 |
| Anthony Sheridan | FB | First | 1993 |
| Bill Loskiewictz | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Billy Canady | FB | Third | 2003 |
| Billy Canady | Base | Third | 2004 |
| Bob Collins | FB | Second | 1979 |
| Brandon Brigman | Bask | Third | 2000 |
| Brandon Brigman | Bask | Second | 2001 |
| Bryan Navin | FB | Second | 2001 |
| Cantrell Fletcher | Bask | Second | 2000 |
| Cantrell Fletcher | Bask | First | 2001 |
| Charles Williams | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Chris Caserio | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Chris Marrone | FB | First | 1992 |
| Chris Scott-Peters | FB | Third | 2001 |
| Damon Reid | Bask | Third | 1990 |
| Daryl Nelson | FB | First | 1987 |
| David "Meatball" Crawford | Bask | Third | 2000 |
| Devon Fowler | Bask | Second | 1998 |
| Doug Rubino | Base | First | 1995 |
| Ed Cook | FB | First | 1979 |
| Ed McDuffie | FB | First | 2002 |
| Eddie James | FB | First | 1986 |
| Ernie Cimadamore | FB | First | 1978 |
| Frank Caccuro | FB | First | 1988 |
| Frank Fisher | FB | Third | 1984 |
| Hakim Byrd | Bask | Second | 2020 |
| Hayes Clark | FB | Third | 1989 |
| James Fowler | Bask | Third | 1997 |
| Jason Guerrera | FB | Second | 1995 |
| Jason Guerrera | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Jerry Smith | FB | First | 1976 |
| Jim "Boots" Paylor | FB | First | 1998 |
| Jim Romeo | Base | Third | 1981 |
| Jimmy Porreca | FB | Second | 2002 |
| Jimmy Porreca | Base | Third | 2003 |
| Joe Boylan | FB | First | 1990 |
| Joe Esposito | FB | Second | 1974 |
| Joe Scavetti | Base | Second | 1999 |
| Joe Wood | Base | Second | 1984 |
| John "Bear" DiFeliciantonio | FB | First | 1972 |
| John DeStefano | Base | Third | 1983 |
| John Masiocchi | FB | Second | 1977 |
| Kevin Joyce | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Len Nelson | FB | First | 1983 |
| Lloyd Ranson | Bask | Second | 1974 |
| Lou Marchetti | Base | Second | 1995 |
| Lou Spadaccini | Base | Third | 1990 |
| Lou Spadaccini | Base | First | 1991 |
| Lou Spadaccini | Base | First | 1992 |
| Marc Marrone | FB | First | 1985 |
| Marques Slocum | FB | First | 2003 |
| Marty Campbell | Bask | Second | 1979 |
| Marty Campbell | Bask | First | 1980 |
| Masai Skief | FB | Second | 1997 |
| Mike "Benji" Gillespie | FB | Third | 2002 |
| Mike Carpinella | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Mike Corba | FB | Third | 1986 |
| Mike Ferraiolo | Base | Second | 1997 |
| Mike Fitzsimmons | FB | First | 1982 |
| Mike Gallagher | FB | Second | 1991 |
| Mike Giovinetti | FB | First | 1990 |
| Mike Keele | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Mike Roccato | Base | Third | 1982 |
| Nasario Dunn | FB | First | 1977 |
| Nick Brunetti | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Nick DelPercio | Base | First | 1991 |
| Nick Martino | Base | First | 1982 |
| Pasquale "Pat" Narducci | FB | Third | 2000 |
| Ralph DiMeo | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Rashid Bey | Bask | Second | 1994 |
| Ray Russo | Base | Second | 1992 |
| Ray Russo | Base | First | 1993 |
| Richard Cunningham | Bask | Second | 2002 |
| Richard Cunningham | Bask | Second | 2003 |
| Richard Cunningham | Bask | Third | 2004 |
| Rob Carfagno | Base | First | 1988 |
| Robert Taylor | Bask | Second | 2001 |
| Rocky Fogarino | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Ron Rosati | FB | Third | 1983 |
| Sal Laimo | Base | Third | 1993 |
| Scott Oster | FB | First | 1994 |
| Steve Benton | Bask | Third | 1984 |
| Steve Benton | Bask | First | 1985 |
| Tim Barry | FB | Second | 1981 |
| Tom Daly | Base | First | 2003 |
| Tom Noreski | FB | Third | 1976 |
| Victor Thomas | Bask | First | 1997 |
| Adam Malatino | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Aidan Baur | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Aidan Baur | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Albert Baur | Base | First | 2009 |
| Albert Baur | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Albert DiDomenico | Base | Second | 2006 |
| Antonio "Scoop" Jardine | Bask | Second | 2007 |
| Bay To | Base | First | 2014 |
| Brian Verratti | Base | First | 2016 |
| Charlie Jerla | Base | First | 2014 |
| Chris Ings | Bask | Second | 2019 |
| Chris Palmer | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Chris Wells | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Christian Barmore | FB | First | 2017 |
| Colin Eiser | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Colin Eiser | Base | First | 2017 |
| Colin Eiser | Base | First | 2018 |
| Danny Stewart | Bask | Third | 2009 |
| Danny Stewart | Bask | Second | 2010 |
| Darrell Dulany | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Derrick "D.J." Rivera | Bask | Second | 2005 |
| Derrick "D.J." Rivera | Bask | First | 2006 |
| Derrick Stewart | Bask | Third | 2011 |
| Derrick Stewart | Bask | Third | 2012 |
| Dhamir Cosby-Roundtree | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| Dhamir Cosby-Roundtree | Bask | First | 2017 |
| Dymir Montague | Bask | Third | 2018 |
| Earl Pettis | Bask | Third | 2005 |
| Earl Pettis | Bask | Third | 2006 |
| Ethan "E" Pritchett | Base | Third | 2016 |
| Gino Tripodi | Base | Second | 2015 |
| Hiram "H" Bowman | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Jamal Custis | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Jamal Custis | FB | Second | 2013 |
| Jamal Wilson | Bask | Third | 2008 |
| Ja'Quan Newton | Bask | Second | 2012 |
| Ja'Quan Newton | Bask | First | 2013 |
| Ja'Quan Newton | Bask | First | 2014 |
| Jared Healey | Base | First | 2017 |
| Jaron Macon | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Jeff Ciocco | Base | First | 2016 |
| Jimmy Kerrigan | Base | Second | 2011 |
| Jimmy Kerrigan | Base | First | 2012 |
| Joe Kinee | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Joe Kinee | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Joe Messina | Base | Second | 2018 |
| Joey Armata | Base | Second | 2008 |
| Joey Armata | Base | Second | 2009 |
| Joey Gorman | Base | First | 2011 |
| Joey Gorman | Base | First | 2012 |
| John Davis | Bask | Second | 2011 |
| John Davis | Bask | Second | 2012 |
| John Davis | Bask | Second | 2013 |
| John La Motta | Base | Third | 2013 |
| Josh Ockimey | Base | First | 2012 |
| Josh Ockimey | Base | First | 2013 |
| Josh Ockimey | Base | First | 2014 |
| Justin Curtin | Base | Third | 2014 |
| Kadeem Custis | FB | Second | 2007 |
| Kadeem Custis | FB | First | 2008 |
| Khalil Roane | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Khalil Roane | FB | Third | 2015 |
| Lamin Fulton | Bask | First | 2011 |
| Leddie Brown | FB | Second | 2017 |
| Mark Donato | Base | First | 2008 |
| Mark Donato | Base | First | 2009 |
| Mark Donato | Base | First | 2010 |
| Mark Hatty | FB | Third | 2006 |
| Mark McPherson | FB | First | 2006 |
| Marty Venafro | Base | Third | 2012 |
| Matt McKeown | Base | First | 2015 |
| Michael DiFrancesco | FB | Third | 2014 |
| Mike "Zoom" Zolk | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Mike "Zoom" Zolk | Base | First | 2011 |
| Mike Riverso | Base | Second | 2010 |
| Nicky D'Amore | Base | First | 2016 |
| Pat Doudican | Base | First | 2014 |
| Phil Sanborn | Base | Third | 2017 |
| Quade Green | Bask | Second | 2015 |
| Quade Green | Bask | First | 2016 |
| Quade Green | Bask | First | 2017 |
| Rick Jackson | Bask | First | 2006 |
| Rick Jackson | Bask | First | 2007 |
| R.J. McGettigan | Base | Second | 2017 |
| Robert Wright | Bask | First | 2022 |
| Sharif Custis | FB | Second | 2011 |
| Sharif Custis | FB | Second | 2012 |
| Stan "Buddy" Visack | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Tommy Nardini | Base | First | 2015 |
| Tony Chennault | Bask | Second | 2009 |
| Tony Chennault | Bask | First | 2010 |
| Tyreek Duren | Bask | Third | 2009 |
| Tyreek Duren | Bask | First | 2010 |
| Tysheem Johnson | FB | Third | 2017 |
| Tysheem Johnson | FB | First | 2018 |
| Vinny Vaccone | Base | First | 2015 |
| Will Huff | FB | First | 2009 |
| Zane Martin | Bask | Second | 2016 |
| North Catholic | |||
| Barry Brodzinski | Bask | Second | 1972 |
| Barry Brodzinski | Bask | First | 1973 |
| Bill Garrison | Base | Second | 1984 |
| Bill Small | FB | First | 1986 |
| Blake Graham | FB | Second | 2008 |
| Bob Hopkins | Base | Third | 2009 |
| Bob Kueny | FB | Third | 1977 |
| Bob Plumley | Base | Second | 1982 |
| Brian Boss | FB | Third | 1996 |
| Brian Mitchell | FB | First | 2002 |
| Charlie Klink | FB | Second | 2005 |
| Chris Bonecorse | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Chris Hanssens | FB | Third | 1985 |
| Chris Heck | Base | Second | 1994 |
| Chris Heck | Base | First | 1995 |
| Chris James | FB | Third | 2007 |
| Chris Wenger | Base | Third | 2005 |
| Chuck Killian | FB | First | 1984 |
| Chuck Morganti | FB | Second | 1987 |
| Chuck Morganti | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Craig Kubis | Base | Second | 2004 |
| Dan Devine | Base | Third | 1989 |
| Dan Galiczynski | FB | Third | 1978 |
| Dan Galiczynski | Base | Third | 1979 |
| Dan Hanratty | FB | Second | 1985 |
| Dan Mackafee | Base | Second | 1993 |
| Dan Szychulski | Base | Second | 2001 |
| Daryl Robinson | FB | Third | 2005 |
| Daryl Robinson | FB | First | 2006 |
| Dave Gill | FB | Second | 1972 |
| Dave Heineman | Base | Second | 1988 |
| Dave Mastropietro | Base | Second | 1986 |
| Dave Mastropietro | Base | First | 1987 |
| David D. Williams | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Dennis Cranston | FB | Third | 1994 |
| Derrek Etsell | Base | Second | 2007 |
| Don Hobson | Bask | Third | 1974 |
| Don Speechley | FB | Second | 1975 |
| Ed Terwilliger | FB | First | 1986 |
| Eugene "U-Turn" Byrd | FB | Second | 2009 |
| Fred Ehrmann | Base | Second | 1983 |
| Harry Ulmer | FB | First | 1978 |
| Hector Guzman | FB | Third | 2004 |
| Hugh Gallagher | FB | Second | 1988 |
| Jamie Makowski | FB | Third | 1987 |
| Javier Barreto |