1994
STATE PAROCHIAL GROUP 1
SEMIFINAL
  St. Joseph (Hammonton) 15, St. Augustine 8: The Hermits lost the total yardage battle, 234-154, even though it ran 25 more plays. This was the teams' second meeting of the season. SA won the first, 21-7. A missed 30-yard field goal set up the Hermits' TD; the ball hit a SJ player while still in the field of play and the Hermits recovered at the 8. Dan Flamma scored two plays later from the 3, then added a conversion run to provide an 8-7 lead.

1995
STATE PAROCHIAL GROUP 1
SEMIFINAL
  St. Augustine 10, St. Joseph (Hammonton) 6: The Hermits scored the first 10 points thanks to a 37-yard run by Johnny Carter (15-118) and PAT/FG by Geoff Allen. The win was preserved in the waning moments when Phil Brunozzi recovered an onsides kick.
FINAL
  St. Augustine 30, St. Mary (Rutherford) 8: In year No. 7 of the program's existence, third-year coach Frank Fucetola steered the Hermits to the state championship. The absence of star rusher Johnny Carter proved to be no problem as Delray Pointer (18-123, two) and Dan Flamma (14-119) combined for three TDs. Jesse Cornely attempted just three passes, but one was a 64-yard TD to T.J. Meyers.   

2001
STATE PAROCHIAL GROUP 3
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Joseph (Montvale) 42, St. Augustine 6: The Hermits surrendered the first 21 points and could not battle back into contention. Their score, off a fake punt, came on a 60-yard pass from Jeff Hoover to Jamaal Forman.

2008
STATE PAROCHIAL GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Augustine 21, Notre Dame 17: The Hermits seized this win with the help of a 15-3 edge in the second half. Bill Giberson returned a punt 50 yards for a TD and Dustin Thomas (7-for-14, 148) connected with Gabe Voumard (5-119) for a 79-yard score. Linebacker Matt Piotrowicz' last-minute interception ended the drama.
SEMIFINAL
  Bergen Catholic 42, St. Augustine 0: This one was over by halftime (35-0). Bill Giberson managed to turn three catches into 75 yards.

2009
STATE PAROCHIAL GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  Seton Hall Prep 49, St. Augustine 14: Both teams entered with 8-0 records, but SHP won in going-away fashion after the Hermits scored first on Gabe Voumard's 31-yard interception return. They also scored last, again thanks to Voumard (6-yard pass from Justin Thomas).

2012
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  Don Bosco Prep 42, St. Augustine 14: The Hermits' TDs were provided by rusher Calvin Cass (35-84). A week earlier, he'd rushed for 226 yards and six TDs as the Hermits waffled Pleasantville, 42-12, for the program's 100th victory.

2013
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Augustine 45, St. Joseph (Metuchen) 28: Junior Lamont Harris slapped together an all-time performance, rushing 40 times for 330 yards and four TDs while adding three catches for 45 yards. The 330 total was just six yards short of the most ever by a Cape-Atlantic player. SA trailed, 28-24, heading into the fourth quarter. Harris ran for the final three scores. Tyler Capille racked up three sacks and recovered a fumble to set up the score that created a 10-point lead. Kyle Snow contributed nine points on six PAT and a field goal.
SEMIFINAL
  St. Peter's Prep 34, St. Augustine 0: Down by just 7-0, the Hermits twice failed to convert red zone vistis in the second quarter. Jonathan Hilliman scampered 54 yards on the first play beyond halftime for one of his three six-pointers.

2014
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  Don Bosco Prep 42, St. Augustine 21: Four of DBP's six TDs covered more than 25 yards and the highlight was a 98-yard pick six. Lamont Harris churned for 187 yards on 40 carries and scored one TD. He also tallied on a 60-yard pass from Jose Tabora, who added a rushing score.

2015
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Joseph (Montvale) 28, St. Augustine 0: This result was quite the eyebrow-raiser -- the top-seeded Hermits were 8-0 and hosting a playoff for the first time since 2009. One bright tidbit: Kyle Dobbins gained 108 yards on 24 carries. That performance raised his season total 1,382, most ever by a Cape-Atlantic sophomore.

2016
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  Bergen Catholic 57, St. Augustine 33: TDs on its fnal six possessions of the first half gave BC a 50-13 lead. This result was particularly shocking because SA had won every game by at least 17 points. Josh Zamot passed for two TDs. Josh Ennis rushed for two scores while adding a third on a reception.

2017
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  Bergen Catholic 56, St. Augustine 21: Chris Allen pinpointed Xavier File for a pair of touchdowns and Shamere Collins experienced quite the thrill, thanks to a 95-yard kickoff return.

2018
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Joseph (Montvale) 16, St. Augustine 8: The Hermits did hang tough against New Jersey's second-ranked powerhouse, Their score was provided by Charles Chiango, thanks to a 72-yard interception return.

2019
STATE NON-PUBLIC GROUP 4
QUARTERFINAL
  St. Augustine 20, Seton Hall Prep 14: One play after SHP took its first lead, Austin Leyman connected with Carnell Davis for an 80-yard score. Isaiah Raikes and Leyman posted rushing TDs.
SEMIFINAL
  St. Peter's Prep 35, St. Augustine 28: The Hermits yielded the final 14 points after taking the lead on Austin Leyman's 5-yard TD pass to Carnell Davis and Kenneth Selby's 45-yard interception return. Kanye Udoh rushed for 138 yards and one TD.