Coaches' All-Catholic FB Teams, 2000-
Return to TedSilary.com Home Page
| Pos. | Player | School |
| 2000 | ||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Greg Schaible | LaS |
| L | Tom McHugh | Bonn |
| L | John Connors | Prep |
| L | Pat Spadaro | Prep |
| L | Matt Battipaglia | Prep |
| TE | Scott Paxson | Roman |
| WR | Ryan Barksdale | O'H |
| WR | Kevin LeSage | Bonn |
| QB | Gabe Marabella | LaS |
| RB | Kevin Jones | O'H |
| RB | Kyle Ambrogi | Prep |
| RB | Joe McCourt | Roman |
| K | Pat Kaiser | Prep |
| K | Joe McCourt | Roman |
| P | Joe Dumas | Ryan |
| Defense | ||
| L | Scott Paxson | Roman |
| L | Mike Mailey | Prep |
| L | Eric Bayliss | Bonn |
| E/OLB | Joe McCourt | Roman |
| E/OLB | Sean Heenan | Prep |
| ILB | Pat Murphy | O'H |
| ILB | Ed Sabia | LaS |
| ILB | Steve Wagner | Prep |
| B | Joe Dumas | Ryan |
| B | David O'Beirne | Prep |
| B | B.J. "Butch" Hogan | O'H |
| B | Kevin LeSage | Bonn |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Ryan Lauterborn | North |
| L | John Kok | O'H |
| L | Ryan Brody | Roman |
| L | Andrew Kamnik | Ryan |
| L | Pat Sweeney | O'H |
| L | Matt Scott | LaS |
| L | Kevin McLaughlin | North |
| L | Andrew Runowski | Roman |
| TE | Ted Murphy | North |
| WR | Derek Talley | Judge |
| WR | Mike Gallagher | North |
| QB | Mike McGann | Prep |
| RB | Ryan Parfitt | LaS |
| RB | Paul Kollhoff | Bonn |
| K | None | |
| P | Ken Kempf | LaS |
| Defense | ||
| L | Tim Giangiulio | Prep |
| L | Ryan Cannon | O'H |
| L | Joe Montanye | Judge |
| L | Nate Moss | LaS |
| L | Kevin McLaughlin | North |
| E/OLB | Keith Roemhild | Ryan |
| E/OLB | Emmett McGowan | LaS |
| ILB | Tom Lynch | Judge |
| ILB | Joe Boland | Bonn |
| ILB | Dom Armideo | Bonn |
| ILB | Dan Szychulski | North |
| B | F.J. Wesner | Prep |
| B | Nick Pinto | Ryan |
| B | Craig Haywood | O'H |
| B | Matt Weidenmiller | North |
| B | Kevin Dolan | Roman |
| B | Paris Farrell | Prep |
| BLUE DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Tony Colletti | McD |
| L | Luke Erb | McD |
| L | Joe Hallinan | Carr |
| L | Pat Hood | Wood |
| L | Justin Adams | Neum |
| TE | Mickey King | Dough |
| WR | Maurice Stovall | Carr |
| WR | Steve Schiavo | Neum |
| QB | Sean McGovern | Dough |
| RB | Charlie Hurley | Carr |
| RB | Brian Mattaway | Carr |
| RB | Abdul Sesay | West |
| K | Marty Higgins | Carr |
| P | Sean Hughes | McD |
| P | Mickey King | Dough |
| Defense | ||
| L | Jeff Vanak | Carr |
| L | Brian O'Meara | McD |
| L | Keary Packer | Wood |
| E/OLB | Brian Mattaway | Carr |
| E/OLB | Joe Lamina | C-E |
| ILB | Drew Shaw | Carr |
| ILB | Don Watkins | McD |
| ILB | Ed Jeffery | Neum |
| B | Charlie Hurley | Carr |
| B | Dave Melcher | McD |
| B | Mike D'Elia | West |
| B | Bill Hartley | Wood |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Kyle Kosinski | Wood |
| L | Dave Parks | McD |
| L | Tom White | Wood |
| L | Kevin Clark | Dough |
| L | Joe Domzalski | C-E |
| L | Mike Mann | K-K |
| TE | Michael Bazemore | West |
| WR | Leonard Hodges | Dough |
| WR | Brandon Smith | Wood |
| QB | Derek Zambino | Carr |
| RB | Chris Smith | McD |
| RB | Bill Hartley | Wood |
| RB | Chris Papandrea | C-E |
| RB | Pasquale Narducci | Neum |
| K | None | |
| P | None | |
| Defense | ||
| L | Jay Harvey-Jenkins | Neum |
| L | Mario Troia | Carr |
| L | Mike Mann | K-K |
| E/OLB | Tony Colletti | McD |
| E/OLB | Jim Argondezzi | K-K |
| E/OLB | Roy Pomarico | Neum |
| E/OLB | Abdulai Sesay | West |
| ILB | Tim LeBold | Dough |
| ILB | Chris Papandrea | C-E |
| ILB | Michael Bazemore | West |
| B | Mike Malandra | Carr |
| B | Mickey King | Dough |
| B | Phil Brazil | C-E |
| B | Mike Burghardt | C-E |
| B | Nick Salamone | K-K |
2001 |
||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Steve Ricci | Judge |
| L | John Connors | Prep |
| L | Mike "Tuna" Bucella | O'H |
| L | Pat Sweeney | O'H |
| L | Ryan "Goose" Nase | Judge |
| TE | Joe Boland | Bonn |
| WR | Kevin LeSage | Bonn |
| WR | Pete Chromiak | Prep |
| QB | Vince Gallagher | Prep |
| RB | Kyle Ambrogi | Prep |
| RB | Anthony Heygood | O'H |
| RB | Justin O'Brien | Judge |
| K | Chris Schrader | Bonn |
| P | Brian Donohoe | LaS |
| Defense | ||
| L | Mike Mailey | Prep |
| L | Mike Kozak | Bonn |
| L | Mike Kelley | LaS |
| E/OLB | Adam Hepp | Prep |
| E/OLB | Chris Galbally | LaS |
| ILB | Dom Armideo | Bonn |
| ILB | Ed Sabia | LaS |
| ILB | Tom Lynch | Judge |
| B | Kevin LeSage | Bonn |
| B | Dan Jones | Prep |
| B | Kevin Dolan | Roman |
| B | Jim McAteer | Judge |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Mike Minetti | Prep |
| C | Mike Whalen | Bonn |
| L | Rich Ott | Ryan |
| L | Steve Mair | Prep |
| L | Justin Mooney | North |
| L | Tim Flynn | LaS |
| L | Ryan Brody | Roman |
| TE | Dave Quaintance | Ryan |
| WR | Harry Dougherty | O'H |
| WR | Mike Haigh | Judge |
| QB | Mike Stauffer | Bonn |
| RB | Sean Miller | LaS |
| RB | Jason Smith | Bonn |
| RB | Paul Kollhoff | Bonn |
| RB | Tom Maisch | Roman |
| K | None | |
| P | None | |
| Defense | ||
| L | Dave Quaintance | Ryan |
| L | Tim Giangiulio | Prep |
| L | John Popplewell | North |
| L | Ryan Loftus | Judge |
| E/OLB | Pat McCarthy | Bonn |
| E/OLB | Matt Mascio | O'H |
| E/OLB | J.P. Bradley | Roman |
| ILB | Greg Silenok | Ryan |
| ILB | Brian Tracz | Prep |
| ILB | Andrew Wood | O'H |
| ILB | Mike "Pio" Piotrowicz | North |
| B | Dan Waters | LaS |
| B | Chris Kozole | Ryan |
| B | Craig Haywood | O'H |
| B | Chris Eccles | Bonn |
| B | Joe O'Donnell | O'H |
| B | Brian Hannan | North |
| B | Ryan Dopkin | Roman |
| BLUE DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Bill Jacobs | C-E |
| C | Dom D'Alicandro | Carr |
| L | Jason Howard | Wood |
| L | Matt Brazil | C-E |
| L | John Vanak | Carr |
| L | Brian O'Meara | McD |
| TE | Al Meacham | Neum |
| WR | Maurice Stovall | Carr |
| WR | Dave Lorditch | Wood |
| QB | John Spinosa | Wood |
| RB | Curtis "Boonah" Brinkley | West |
| RB | Steve Slaton | C-E |
| RB | Chris Scott-Peters | Neum |
| K | Robert McHugh | McD |
| P | Robert McHugh | McD |
| Defense | ||
| L | Keary Packer | Wood |
| L | Brian O'Meara | McD |
| L | Pat Kelly | Carr |
| E/OLB | John DiCamillo | McD |
| E/OLB | Vince Lynam | Carr |
| ILB | Mark Meighan | Neum |
| ILB | Joe Lamina | C-E |
| ILB | Brandon Edwards | McD |
| B | Maurice Stovall | Carr |
| B | Bill Hartley | Wood |
| B | Dan Quinn | C-E |
| B | Robert Ramsey | West |
| B | Bryan Navin | Neum |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Josh Parkes | McD |
| L | Ed McDuffie | Neum |
| L | Will Grant | West |
| L | Joe Cocco | Carr |
| L | Jimmy John McElvaney | Dough |
| L | Adam Gullotti | McD |
| TE | Jeff Beach | McD |
| WR | Matt Miller | Dough |
| WR | Jonathan Jackson | West |
| QB | Sean McGovern | Dough |
| RB | James Roderick | Carr |
| RB | Brandon Edwards | McD |
| RB | Bob Prieto | Wood |
| K | Ian Lawrence | K-K |
| P | Anthony Ciccaglione | K-K |
| Defense | ||
| L | Will Grant | West |
| L | Matt Brazil | C-E |
| L | James Roderick | Carr |
| E/OLB | Vince Salvatore | C-E |
| E/OLB | James Jefferson | Dough |
| E/OLB | Rocco Fusco | K-K |
| ILB | Mike Cutone | Carr |
| ILB | Albert Davis | Dough |
| ILB | Ameel Johnson | West |
| ILB | Nolan Biron | Wood |
| ILB | Paul Rambo | Carr |
| B | Mark "Shark" Finley | McD |
| B | P.J. Chipman | McD |
| B | Jonathan Jackson | West |
| B | Dave Lorditch | Wood |
2002 |
||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Bruce Pohlot | LaS |
| L | John Quinn | Prep |
| L | Chris Galbally | LaS |
| L | Chris Guinter | Roman |
| L | Matt Blong | Bonn |
| TE | Bill Freiling | Ryan |
| TE | Kevin Walker | Prep |
| WR | Paul McNichol | Bonn |
| WR | Carl Peterson | Judge |
| QB | Matt Stefanski | Prep |
| QB | Brian Mitchell | North |
| RB | Pat Kaiser | Prep |
| RB | Anthony Heygood | O'H |
| RB | Johnny Ortiz | Roman |
| K | Pat Kaiser | Prep |
| P | Chris Schrader | Bonn |
| Defense | ||
| L | Omar Emmens | O'H |
| L | Kevin Donohoe | LaS |
| L | John Quinn | Prep |
| E/OLB | Chris Galbally | LaS |
| E/OLB | Matt Parkhurst | Prep |
| ILB | Brian Tracz | Prep |
| ILB | Tom Bowen | Roman |
| ILB | Corey Cannon | O'H |
| B | Dan Jones | Prep |
| B | Brian Mitchell | North |
| B | Paul Roken | Judge |
| B | Matt McGurkin | LaS |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Tom Sugden | Roman |
| C | John Brewster | Prep |
| L | Tom Hayden | O'H |
| L | Eric Ellis | O'H |
| L | Jeff Grimmie | Roman |
| L | Mike Buscaglia | Prep |
| TE | Bernie Mullen | Judge |
| WR | Sean Agnew | LaS |
| WR | Kyle Gallagher | Ryan |
| WR | Steve Quinn | Prep |
| QB | Andre Sloan-El | Roman |
| RB | Brian Donohoe | LaS |
| RB | Joe Zeglinski | Ryan |
| RB | Tom DeVietro | Bonn |
| RB | Brian Tracz | Prep |
| K | Chris Schrader | Bonn |
| P | Shawn Anderson | O'H |
| Defense | ||
| L | Kevin Cahill | Roman |
| L | Brandon Friday | Prep |
| L | Jim Fitzgerald | Judge |
| E/OLB | Rich Prazenica | O'H |
| E/OLB | John Ferdinand | Ryan |
| ILB | Alvin Percival | North |
| ILB | Matt Asciutto | Bonn |
| ILB | Chris Stine | North |
| B | Dave Pasciolla | Bonn |
| B | Craig Haywood | O'H |
| B | Frank Nunan | Bonn |
| B | Brian Hogan | LaS |
| B | Johnny Ortiz | Roman |
| BLUE DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Bill Jacobs | C-E |
| L | Matt Brazil | C-E |
| L | Justin Faust | Carr |
| L | Will Grant | West |
| L | Jim Goodwin | McD |
| L | Kevin Harrigan | Neum |
| TE | Al Meacham | Neum |
| WR | Jonathan Jackson | West |
| WR | Chaz Scott | Carr |
| QB | Pat Brochet | Carr |
| RB | Curtis "Boonah" Brinkley | West |
| RB | Steve Slaton | C-E |
| RB | Jimmy Porreca | Neum |
| K | Robert McHugh | McD |
| P | Robert McHugh | McD |
| Defense | ||
| L | Anthony Mora | Wood |
| L | James Roderick | Carr |
| L | Matt Brazil | C-E |
| E/OLB | Brandon Edwards | McD |
| E/OLB | Ted Kavanagh | K-K |
| ILB | Rob Biernat | C-E |
| ILB | Mike Cutone | Carr |
| ILB | Dan Concannon | Neum |
| B | Dan Quinn | C-E |
| B | Robert Ramsey | West |
| B | Jonathan Jackson | West |
| B | Chaz Scott | Carr |
| B | Mike "Benji" Gillespie | Neum |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Eric Ondik | K-K |
| L | Ed McDuffie | Neum |
| L | Brian Hrynczyszyn | C-E |
| L | Dan Ochnich | Wood |
| L | Jason Collins | K-K |
| L | Jimmy John McElvaney | Dough |
| TE | John Maha | McD |
| WR | Dan McCabe | K-K |
| WR | Ryan McGinley | Wood |
| WR | Dan Quinn | C-E |
| WR | Robert Henderson | McD |
| QB | Brian Gillin | K-K |
| RB | Lamar McPherson | McD |
| RB | Mike Smith | C-E |
| RB | James Roderick | Carr |
| RB | Ryan Stewart | Carr |
| K | Ryan McGoldrick | Carr |
| P | Matt Fischer | C-E |
| Defense | ||
| L | Will Grant | West |
| L | Rafael Calzadilla | K-K |
| L | Steven Williams | West |
| L | Mike Haggerty | McD |
| E/OLB | Brian Hrynczyszyn | C-E |
| E/OLB | John Lachman | Carr |
| ILB | Mike Kruzits | Wood |
| ILB | Chester Roebuck | West |
| ILB | Mark Tipson | McD |
| B | Steven Merlini | McD |
| B | Dan Acevedo | C-E |
| B | Jay Rigg | K-K |
2003 |
||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Dan Byrne | O'H |
| L | Tom Hayden | O'H |
| L | Matt Lowry | O'H |
| L | Mike Buscaglia | Prep |
| L | Mike Robinson | Prep |
| TE | Matt Parkhurst | Prep |
| WR | Carl Peterson | Judge |
| WR | George Flack | Judge |
| QB | Andre Sloan-El | Roman |
| RB | Anthony Heygood | O'H |
| RB | Dan Jones | Prep |
| RB | Joe Zeglinski | Ryan |
| K | Charlie Squitiere | Roman |
| P | Rob Forster | LaS |
| Defense | ||
| L | Matt Parkhurst | Prep |
| L | Brandon Friday | Prep |
| L | Lenny DeMalto | Roman |
| E/OLB | Steve Quinn | Prep |
| E/OLB | Charron Fisher | Roman |
| ILB | Brian Tracz | Prep |
| ILB | Sean Matthews | Roman |
| ILB | Tom Bowen | Roman |
| B | Dan Jones | Prep |
| B | Greg Ambrogi | Prep |
| B | Bob Hogan | O'H |
| B | Brian Hogan | LaS |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Andrew Rocks | LaS |
| L | Phil Vaughan | O'H |
| L | Jim Alberts | Judge |
| L | Earl McNeil | Bonn |
| L | Lenny DeMalto | Roman |
| L | Brendan Gilroy | Prep |
| L | D.J. Cunningham | LaS |
| L | Tim Morris | Ryan |
| TE | Shawn Anderson | O'H |
| TE | Dave Levan | Ryan |
| WR | Rick Ferraiolo | Ryan |
| WR | Jordan McCauley | Bonn |
| WR | Charlie Squitiere | Roman |
| QB | Dale Curry | Judge |
| QB | Mike Lynch | LaS |
| RB | Evin Jones | Roman |
| RB | Matt Gough | O'H |
| RB | Brian Tracz | Prep |
| RB | John Shaw | Prep |
| K | Frank D'Angelo | O'H |
| K | Greg Ambrogi | Prep |
| P | Andrew Case | Bonn |
| P | Tim Wacker | Judge |
| P | Charlie Squitiere | Roman |
| Defense | ||
| L | Kevin Donohoe | LaS |
| L | Jim Fitzgerald | Judge |
| L | Mike Kimpel | O'H |
| L | Paul Titchenell | O'H |
| E/OLB | Frank Jorfi | LaS |
| E/OLB | None | |
| ILB | Anthony Rodriguez | Judge |
| ILB | Anthony DiEmedio | Bonn |
| ILB | Miles Miller | LaS |
| B | Joe Zeglinski | Ryan |
| B | Joe Thompson | Judge |
| B | Steve DeVito | Bonn |
| B | Steve Cook | O'H |
| BLUE DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Eric Ondik | K-K |
| L | Brian Hrynczyszyn | C-E |
| L | Marques Slocum | Neum |
| L | John Haviland | Wood |
| L | John Lachman | Carr |
| TE | Derrell Hand | West |
| WR | John Maddox | West |
| WR | Antoine Stout | Neum |
| QB | Jon Brady | Neum |
| RB | Curtis "Boonah" Brinkley | West |
| RB | Steve Slaton | C-E |
| RB | Ryan Harford | Carr |
| K | Tom Laurich | Wood |
| P | Tom Laurich | Wood |
| Defense | ||
| L | Marques Slocum | Neum |
| L | Pat Kane | Wood |
| L | Sterling Williams | McD |
| E/OLB | Eric Ondik | K-K |
| E/OLB | Anthony Caranci | C-E |
| ILB | Mike Kruzits | Wood |
| ILB | Brian Hrynczyszyn | C-E |
| ILB | Will Bradley | Carr |
| B | Brian Rorick | Carr |
| B | John McFadden | Wood |
| B | Billy Canady | Neum |
| B | Tom Sztubinski | K-K |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Christian Szablowski | Wood |
| L | Matt DeMarco | West |
| L | Jason Collins | K-K |
| L | Jason Devine | Wood |
| L | Mike Gambone | North |
| L | John Gorman | McD |
| L | Kellen Kemp | Dough |
| L | Fran Enright | West |
| TE | Pete Novak | Carr |
| TE | Mike Barainyak | Wood |
| WR | Sammy Ladd | North |
| WR | None | |
| QB | Dane Mangin | Wood |
| RB | Bryan McCartney | Wood |
| RB | Brian Gillin | K-K |
| RB | Dominic Rock | Dough |
| K | None | |
| P | Joe Swoyer | McD |
| Defense | ||
| L | John Lachman | Carr |
| L | Derrell Hand | West |
| L | Alton Williams | Dough |
| E/OLB | Mpanda Castelo | Dough |
| E/OLB | Brian Devlin | Wood |
| E/OLB | David Fitzgerald | West |
| ILB | Bill Gross | Wood |
| ILB | Ryan Biernat | C-E |
| ILB | Frank Baldino | Neum |
| B | Tom Fontaine | West |
| B | Marty O'Hara | C-E |
| B | Terence Nelson | McD |
| B | Shane McNamara | North |
| 2004 | ||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| OFFENSE | ||
| First Team | ||
| C | Jerry Feehery | O'H |
| L | Dan Voss | Prep |
| L | Brendan Gilroy | Prep |
| L | Matt Lowry | O'H |
| L | Joe Glace | O'H |
| TE | Matt Leddy | Prep |
| WR | Steve Quinn | Prep |
| WR | Sean Barksdale | O'H |
| QB | Justin DeCristofaro | Judge |
| RB | John Shaw | Prep |
| RB | Steve Cook | O'H |
| RB | Evin Jones | Roman |
| K | Ryan Juisti | Bonn |
| P | Tim Hoban | Roman |
| Defense | ||
| L | Charlie Noonan | Prep |
| L | John Paul Conneen | O'H |
| L | Mike Nolan | Bonn |
| L | Mike Boyle | Prep |
| L | Christian Barrett | LaS |
| L | Joe Jackson | Ryan |
| E/OLB | Steve Quinn | Prep |
| E/OLB | Rich Canfield | Bonn |
| E/OLB | Mike Marotta | O'H |
| ILB | Matt Licci | Bonn |
| ILB | Andrew Spross | Prep |
| ILB | Chris Smith | Ryan |
| B | Jack Forster | LaS |
| B | Mike Pinto | Ryan |
| B | Cory Jackson | Roman |
| B | Chris Whitney | Prep |
| B | Dave Clement | Prep |
| B | Brian Giacobetti | O'H |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Scott Howley | Prep |
| C | Jim Moore | Roman |
| L | Dave Fremont | Bonn |
| L | Dan Gough | O'H |
| L | John Clifford | LaS |
| L | Carlos Gonzalez | Ryan |
| TE | Tom Green | O'H |
| WR | Mike Heppler | Bonn |
| WR | Tom Hayes | Judge |
| WR | Erik Frazier | Judge |
| QB | Mike Lynch | LaS |
| RB | Joe Zeglinski | Ryan |
| RB | Pat Macaulay | O'H |
| K | Frank D'Angelo | O'H |
| K | Tim Hoban | Roman |
| P | Andrew Case | Bonn |
| Defense | ||
| L | None | |
| E/OLB | Jeff McMahon | Judge |
| E/OLB | Sean Atkinson | Ryan |
| E/OLB | Tim Plona | Roman |
| ILB | Scott Taylor | O'H |
| ILB | George Hudson | LaS |
| ILB | Sean Matthews | Roman |
| B | Joe Thompson | Judge |
| B | Andy Shalbrack | Prep |
| B | Anthony Walters | O'H |
| B | Aaron Pryer | Roman |
| BLUE DIVISION | ||
| OFFENSE | ||
| First Team | ||
| C | Christian Szablowski | Wood |
| L | Ryan Biernat | C-E |
| L | Hector Guzman | North |
| L | Tom Rowinski | Carr |
| L | Matt DeMarco | West |
| L | James Smart | West |
| TE | Pete Novak | Carr |
| TE | Derrell Hand | West |
| WR | Chris Lorditch | Wood |
| WR | John Maddox | West |
| QB | Chris Hanson | Wood |
| QB | Joe Waclawski | North |
| RB | Steve Slaton | C-E |
| RB | Damian Jorden | McD |
| RB | Bryan McCartney | Wood |
| RB | Shane McNamara | North |
| RB | Chris Diaferio | West |
| K | Kevin Lawrence | K-K |
| P | Kevin Lawrence | K-K |
| Defense | ||
| L | Mike Gallagher | Wood |
| L | Barry Porter | McD |
| L | Marques Slocum | West |
| L | Derrell Hand | West |
| E/OLB | Lamar McPherson | McD |
| E/OLB | Anthony Rhoades | West |
| ILB | Ryan Biernat | C-E |
| ILB | Bill Gross | Wood |
| ILB | Chris Matozzo | K-K |
| B | Brian Rorick | Carr |
| B | John McFadden | Wood |
| B | Jeff McClenton | C-E |
| B | Brian Mitros | McD |
| B | John Maddox | West |
| B | Shane McNamara | North |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Offense | ||
| C | Shawn Cochran | McD |
| L | John Gorman | McD |
| L | Mike Gallagher | Wood |
| L | Marques Slocum | West |
| TE | None | |
| WR | Antoine Stout | West |
| WR | Jeff McClenton | C-E |
| WR | Brian Rorick | Carr |
| WR | Daryl Robinson | North |
| QB | None | |
| RB | Brent Christie | Carr |
| RB | Brian Gillin | K-K |
| RB | Bruce Holloman | N-G |
| K | Josiah Morley | West |
| P | Brian Rorick | Carr |
| P | Charles Klink | North |
| Defense | ||
| L | Tom Rowinski | Carr |
| L | Ted Kemzang Nzali | K-K |
| E/OLB | Jermaine Pierce | K-K |
| E/OLB | Brian Gillin | K-K |
| E/OLB | Chris McNicholas | Dough |
| E/OLB | Bryan Howard | Wood |
| E/OLB | Dan Chavis | N-G |
| ILB | Chris Baldwin | N-G |
| ILB | Wayne Donahue | West |
| B | Jason Rigg | K-K |
| B | Harold Davis | West |
| B | Steve Slaton | C-E |
| 2005 | ||
| RED DIVISION | ||
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| C | Joe D'Orazio | Prep |
| L | Jerry Penrose | O'H |
| L | Jim McKenzie | Prep |
| L | Jude Cooke | Judge |
| L | Tim Clarke | La S |
| L | Dan Gough | O'H |
| TE | Matt Leddy | Prep |
| WR | Bill Edger | Prep |
| WR | Rockeed McCarter | Roman |
| QB | Chris Whitney | Prep |
| RB | John Dempsey | O'H |
| RB | Daryl Robinson | North |
| RB | John Shaw | Prep |
| FB | Joe Juisti | O'H |
| K | Tim Edger | Prep |
| P | Pat Quinn | O'H |
| Defense | ||
| L | Charlie Noonan | Prep |
| L | Jewhan Edwards | Roman |
| L | Ed Callahan | O'H |
| E/OLB | Mike Varanavage | Ryan |
| E/OLB | Rockeed McCarter | Roman |
| ILB | Greg Smith | O'H |
| ILB | Scott Taylor | O'H |
| ILB | Josh Howley | Prep |
| B | Anthony Walters | O'H |
| B | Cory Jackson | Roman |
| B | Jack Forster | LaS |
| B | Joe DeCree | Ryan |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Defense | ||
| C | Sean Murray | O'H |
| L | Tim Kelly | Bonn |
| L | Jeff Battipaglia | Prep |
| L | James Dunn | Prep |
| L | Reginald Burton | Roman |
| TE | Drew Wilkins | LaS |
| WR | Dan Jordan | Roman |
| WR | Mark Ryan | Judge |
| WR | Matt Ihlein | LaS |
| QB | Marc Verica | Bonn |
| QB | Anthony Walters | O'H |
| QB | John Harrison | LaS |
| RB | Jamir Livingston | Prep |
| RB | Sean Woods | Roman |
| K | John Hayes | Bonn |
| K | Ryan Cain | LaS |
| P | Charles Klink | North |
| P | Jack Forster | LaS |
| Defense | ||
| L | John McBurnie | LaS |
| L | Doug Andrews | Ryan |
| L | Pat Dix | Bonn |
| L | Ryan Haber | Prep |
| L | Mike Murphy | Judge |
| E/OLB | Steve Wheatley | Bonn |
| E/OLB | Charles Klink | North |
| E/OLB | Jeff McMahon | Judge |
| E/OLB | Todd Cannon | O'H |
| ILB | George Hudson | LaS |
| ILB | Matt Ricci | Bonn |
| ILB | ||